EN
English Français
Start your station
The CloudRadio blog
Radio tips 23 min read

Talk show topics that get listeners calling: 25 ideas

25 talk show topics we'd put on a rundown, each with the question to ask on air, when to run it and what to try if nobody calls, plus real shows behind many of them.

Updated November 12, 2026 · by the CloudRadio team in Montreal

ON AIR ?

Domino's take, in one breath

25 talk show topics for radio, grouped by show and time of day, with the question to ask on air, what to do if nobody calls, and real shows behind many.

Talk show topics that get calls are usually questions a listener can answer from their own life in a sentence or two: a small everyday argument, a first or a worst, a place only people in your town know. Below are the 25 we'd use on air, grouped by the kind of show and the time of day they suit. Each one has the question to ask on air, when to run it and what to try if nobody calls. Many also name a real show that ran it.

Three to start with:

  • "When your phone rings and it isn't family, do you pick up?"
  • "What was your first job, and what did it pay?"
  • "Is a hot dog a sandwich? Call and defend your answer."

You don't need a phone line for any of them. Every question here works with messages, comments or voice notes read on air, so they suit podcasters and solo hosts too.

8 topics that get calls on any show

None of these needs any background from the caller, so they fit almost any format. If you're new to taking calls, start with the first three: each one is easy for a first caller to answer.

1Call or text?

Ask: "When your phone rings and it isn't family, do you pick up?"

CBC Radio's national phone-in Cross Country Checkup put "Is it better to call or text?" to its callers on October 4, 2026, with a psychologist, a dating expert and a linguist weighing in between calls (CBC Listen). The episode notes point to a generational divide between people who like to talk and people who text, which gives you two sides without getting into politics. It works on any weekday show.

If it's quiet: Say what you do yourself ("I let it ring, then text back 'what's up?'") and ask the other camp to call and tell you you're wrong.

2Questions nobody looked up

Ask: "What have you always wondered about and never looked up? Someone listening will know."

Every week on LBC, James O'Brien runs a Mystery Hour: listeners call with a question, and other listeners call with the answer (LBC). Give it the same slot every week so listeners know when to bring their questions.

If it's quiet: Ask the first question yourself, and keep two from the week's messages in reserve.

3Praise or grumble

Ask: "Praise or grumble: give me one sentence on today's game."

BBC Radio Sheffield calls its Praise or Grumble the original football phone-in. Robert Jackson came up with it in November 1986 because, as he told the BBC, the station tended to lose listeners once fans had heard the football results (BBC). BBC Radio 5 Live's 606 runs the same idea nationally after the weekend's matches. Run it in the hour after the event. The format also fits a storm, an election night or the finale of a show your town watched.

If it's quiet: Read the result again for people who just tuned in, then give your own grumble in one sentence.

4How you met

Ask: "How did you meet the person you're with? What did you notice first?"

Nighttime host Delilah takes calls like these. On her site she describes them as stories "about romances, about friends, family, work situations, hardships and triumphs", and she shares them in a weekly podcast series, Have a Little Faith (delilah.com). Run it in the evening, and let each caller decide how much to share.

If it's quiet: Switch to the worst first date. It asks less of the caller than a story about someone they're still with.

5Buy, sell or swap

Ask: "Got something in the garage that someone in town could use? Call and tell us what you want for it."

WTAB in Tabor City, North Carolina ran a Swap Shop from the 1970s until the AM station signed off in March 2025. It filled two hours every weekday morning, with callers announcing what they wanted to buy, sell or trade. Matt Jernigan revived it two months later as a live show on Facebook and YouTube on Friday and Saturday mornings (MyHorryNews). It suits a small-town or community station that can give it the same slot every week.

If it's quiet: Collect a few listings by message before the show, and fill the gaps with community notices. The Swap Shop mixes in birthdays and church events.

6What did you finally pay off?

Ask: "What did you finally pay off this year, and how did it feel?"

The Ramsey Show has listeners who have paid off their debts do a "debt-free scream", and its sign-up page says every scream has to be done in person at Ramsey Solutions headquarters in Franklin, Tennessee (Ramsey Solutions). The topic keeps money talk to stories and good news, which is safer for a host than giving advice. Run it in January or at tax time.

If it's quiet: Book one or two callers in advance: ask for stories by message during the week and call the best ones back. Questions about investing or debt go to a qualified guest.

7Is a hot dog a sandwich?

Ask: "Is a hot dog a sandwich? Call and defend your answer."

A silly argument gets people calling to disagree with the last caller, and this one has an official ruling to read out. The National Hot Dog and Sausage Council says no: "Limiting the hot dog's significance by saying it's 'just a sandwich' is like calling the Dalai Lama 'just a guy'" (NHDSC). Keep it for a morning show, or as the backup when a heavier topic stalls.

If it's quiet: Read the Council's ruling and ask who thinks it's wrong. Keep a tally and read it out every few calls.

8Your first job

Ask: "What was your first job, and what did it pay?"

Almost every adult listening has an answer, and the pay gives each caller a number the audience can react to. It suits weekends and slower hours, when callers have time for a story.

If it's quiet: Tell yours first, with the pay and one detail about the boss.

Morning show topics

Morning listeners are getting ready or driving. Pick questions that take ten seconds to answer, and repeat the question every half hour for people who just tuned in. Which hour suits a call-in at all depends on when your own listeners are around.

9Recline or not?

Ask: "Is it OK to recline your seat on a plane? Yes or no."

A yes-or-no question gets short calls and messages you can count. Keep score on air and promise the final result before you sign off.

If it's quiet: Give the score as it stands, even at 2 to 1, and ask the losing side to call.

10The chore you'd pay to get rid of

Ask: "Which chore would you pay someone to do forever? Mine's ironing."

It suits weekday mornings, when listeners are in the middle of their own chores.

If it's quiet: Name a chore some listeners secretly enjoy, like folding laundry, and ask who'll defend it.

11A thank-you on air

Ask: "Who in [your town] deserves a thank-you on air this week? Tell us what they did."

A gentle topic for a Friday morning on a community station. Tell each caller you'll make sure the person hears it, then do it: a call, a message, or a clip they can share.

If it's quiet: Read one you collected during the week, then ask for more.

Midday and local topics

Local topics are the ones a national show can't copy, and they suit a lunchtime slot on a community radio station. The Swap Shop above belongs in this slot too.

12The place you still miss

Ask: "Which closed shop or restaurant in town do you still miss? What's there now?"

It brings in long-time residents, who can tell the rest of the audience what used to be there. If callers keep naming the same place and its owner is still around, invite them on.

If it's quiet: Name one yourself and describe what you used to order there.

13Fix one thing

Ask: "If you could fix one thing in town tomorrow, what would it be?"

Collect the answers, then invite a city council member to respond to the top three the following week.

If it's quiet: Start with something small and specific, like the pothole on a street everyone uses.

Afternoon drive and sports topics

Drive-time listeners are in the car. Ask them to call once they've parked or on hands-free, and pick questions they can answer from the drive itself. Sports reactions belong here too: praise or grumble works best in the hour after a game.

14The worst intersection

Ask: "Which intersection in town makes you lose your mind?"

Anyone who drives in town has an answer. Send the top answer to the city, or invite someone from the roads department to hear it.

If it's quiet: Name yours, with the street names, and ask who has a worse one.

15Game-day rituals

Ask: "What do you do on game day so your team doesn't lose?"

Run it on the afternoon before a big game, then switch to praise or grumble after the final whistle. Superstition stories are short and easy to tell on the phone.

If it's quiet: Confess your own first.

Late-night topics

Late at night you can give a caller three minutes, so this is the slot for stories.

16Things you can't explain

Ask: "What's happened to you that you still can't explain?"

Coast to Coast AM collects ghost stories ahead of its Halloween show. On September 28, 2026 it asked listeners to email their name, phone number and best ghost story for a chance to tell it on air on Friday, October 30 (Coast to Coast AM).

If it's quiet: Book stories in advance the same way. Ask for them by email or message during the week and call the best ones back.

17Who's working tonight?

Ask: "Who's on the night shift right now? Tell us where you are and what you do."

The question finds the listeners who are at work: a nurse on a break, a truck driver, a baker starting the bread. Each call is a short story about a job most people never see at that hour.

If it's quiet: Say hello to the places you know are open at that hour, like the hospital or the all-night diner, and ask who's there.

Expert hour topics

An expert hour pairs listener questions with a guest who knows the answers. Farm Radio International's guide to call-in programs says a call-in should bring both heat and light: the callers bring stories and opinions, and an invited guest brings the evidence (Farm Radio International). Our guide to booking guests covers finding one, and how to run a radio interview covers the conversation itself.

18What's wrong with my car?

Ask: "What's your car doing that you can't explain? Our mechanic is listening."

NPR's Car Talk is the model: mechanics taking calls from car owners all over the country (NPR). A local mechanic can do the same for an hour a month.

If it's quiet: Ask the mechanic to answer the questions they hear most often at the counter.

19Garden questions

Ask: "What's going wrong in your garden this week?"

On BBC Radio 4's Gardeners' Question Time, a panel of horticultural experts answers questions from a live audience, recorded in a different location each week (BBC). Book a local nursery owner for spring and fall weekends.

If it's quiet: Collect questions by message during the week, so the first ten minutes are already full.

20Ask the pharmacist

Ask: "What health question have you been meaning to ask someone?"

Book a pharmacist, a nurse or a dietitian, and collect questions all week. The host keeps the questions coming. Diagnoses and treatment advice stay with the guest, who should say when a caller needs to see their own doctor.

If it's quiet: Have the guest answer the three questions they get most often at work.

Music show topics

On a music show, the topic gives you a reason to play the next song.

21The song that takes you back

Ask: "Which song puts you right back in one year of your life? Tell us the song and the year."

NPR's All Songs Considered ran a version of this for Mother's Day 2024: it asked listeners to email a voice memo about a song that reminds them of their mom, saying what it means to them, for an upcoming episode (Michigan Public). Voice memos work for any show without a phone line.

Play as many as you can before the hour ends, and ask each caller what was going on in their life that year.

If it's quiet: Play your own pick first and tell the story behind it in 20 seconds.

22Your first concert

Ask: "What was the first concert you ever went to? Are you proud of it?"

Here & Now co-host Deepa Fernandes put the question to her own colleagues in October 2022, when her teenage daughter was about to go to her first concert, and the show aired their memories (WBUR).

The second question lets people confess, and the confessions are the funny calls.

If it's quiet: Admit yours, especially if it's embarrassing.

Topics for student and youth radio

School and college stations need topics about students' own lives that are safe for a classroom. Keep real names out of anything critical, and run sensitive topics past your faculty adviser. World College Radio Day 2026 was on October 2, with more than 700 college stations in over 50 countries expected to take part. Plan next year's special around it (CollegeRadio.org). Our guide to starting a student radio station covers the setup.

23First-day advice

Ask: "What do you wish someone had told you on your first day here?"

Vermont Public's Vermont Edition ran it as a call-in on September 3, 2014, asking "What one piece of advice do you wish someone had told you before you went off to college?", with a college media studies chair and a residential life director as guests (Vermont Public).

Run it in the first weeks of term, and save the best answers for next year's orientation.

If it's quiet: Record a few answers in the hallway before the show and open with them.

24Phones in class

Ask: "Should phones be allowed in class, or locked away until the bell?"

Students and teachers both have a stake, so invite one of each to argue it before you open the lines.

If it's quiet: Read your school's actual rule and ask who thinks it's fair.

25Ten years from now

Ask: "Where will you be in ten years? Give us one specific prediction."

Record each prediction and promise to play them back at graduation.

If it's quiet: Ask club presidents or team captains to go first.

Turn today's news into a topic

A news story becomes a call-in topic when you turn it into a question listeners answer from their own life. A headline like "the city is raising downtown parking fees" gives callers nothing to add; "What would you give up to keep parking downtown free?" lets anyone who drives into town answer. Give the facts in a sentence or two, then ask the question.

Check the story in at least one reliable outlet before you build a segment on it, say on air where the facts come from, and correct them on air if they change. Leave tragedies out: a death, a disaster or a crime with victims is not a call-in topic. For a news event many listeners just watched, like an election result, the praise or grumble format above works.

A question for every month

Seasonal topics are the easiest to plan, because you know they're coming. Pencil in one a month, then add the news as it happens. The seasons below are for the Northern Hemisphere, and holiday dates vary by country, so adjust for where you broadcast.

Month and hook Question to ask
January: New Year's resolutions "Which resolution have you already broken?"
February: Valentine's Day (February 14) "What's the worst Valentine's gift you've ever received?"
March: International Women's Day (March 8) "Which woman shaped your life, and does she know it?"
April: April Fools' Day, Earth Day (April 22) "What's the best prank you've ever pulled, or fallen for?"
May: Mother's Day in the US and Canada, exams "What's the best advice your mom ever gave you?"
June: Graduations, Father's Day "What do you wish you'd known on graduation day?"
July: Road trips, summer jobs "What's the worst road trip you've ever been on?"
August: Vacations, shopping for school "What did you forget to pack, and really regret?"
September: Back to school "What did you love, or dread, about the first day of school?"
October: Thanksgiving in Canada, Halloween "What's the scariest thing that ever happened to you, for real?"
November: Thanksgiving in the US, the first snow "What are you grateful for this year that you weren't last year?"
December: Holiday traditions, the year in review "What's the worst gift you've ever given?"

On a morning show, open with these on the day itself and come back to the best answers the next morning, including answers listeners recorded overnight as shout-outs. Our breakfast show ideas pair well with them.

If the lines stay quiet

Farm Radio International's guide to call-in programs, drawn up with producers of CBC's Cross Country Checkup, gives three reasons nobody calls: the topic isn't of general interest, the question is unfocused, or listeners want to hear more before they join in (Farm Radio International). Most of the fixes happen before the show.

The first fix is the question itself. Farm Radio's example: instead of "How was your maize harvest this year?", ask "Did you harvest enough maize to feed your family all year?" Their rule of thumb is that the question should have the word "you" in it. The same fix works for any topic:

Weak

  • "Today we're talking about phones and texting. Give us a call."

Better

  • "My sister hasn't answered a phone call since 2019. She texts back 'what's up?' while it's still ringing. Are you a caller or a texter? Callers, phone in at [phone number]. Texters, you know what to do: [text line]."

The better version opens on one specific story, asks a question with "you" in it, and gives each side its own way to answer. The weak one names a subject and leaves listeners to work out what they're supposed to say.

  • Book two or three callers before you go on.

    Farm Radio suggests booking a few callers to start the show. Coast to Coast AM picks callers for its Halloween show from stories listeners email in (topic 16).

  • Post the question days ahead.

    Put it on WhatsApp, social media and your newsletter. Read the best written replies on air, or book those people as callers.

  • Open with recorded answers.

    Record a few people answering the question during the week and play two or three at the top of the segment. Farm Radio calls these vox pops.

  • Give your own answer.

    One specific sentence with a detail in it gives the first caller something to agree with or argue against.

  • Have a guest who likes to talk.

    Farm Radio's guide says a knowledgeable, talkative guest fills the time while you wait for callers.

  • Switch to your backup.

    Keep a quick yes-or-no question ready, like the plane seat, and move to it after two tries at the main one.

For a one-hour show, we'd plan two or three topics and one backup.

Put callers on air

The call itself comes from your own setup, mixed with your microphone before it reaches your encoder. The two simplest ways are a phone on speaker next to your microphone, or a phone wired into your mixing console. We cover both in our guide to putting callers on air.

Replay the best calls

Air your best calls again: a five-minute best-of in a quiet hour, or a teaser for next week's topic. Delilah turns hers into a podcast series. Tell callers when they go on air that you may replay their call.

Record the show on your own computer while you're live. The BUTT encoder, for example, can record your broadcast locally while it streams (BUTT); our BUTT setup guide covers connecting it to your station. Then cut the best calls together in Audacity or other recording and editing software.

See which topics held your listeners

Write down the minute each topic starts. You can also type the topic into your encoder's now-playing title, so listeners see it in the player (see sending track titles from your encoder). After the show, compare your rundown with your listener count. A topic where the count holds or climbs is worth running again. If the count drops in the first few minutes, try a sharper question or a different hour before you give up on it.

Topics to avoid or handle with care

Some topics lose listeners or create legal trouble. Skip these, or prepare properly before you open the lines.

  • Rumors about real people. An unverified claim about a named person can land you in legal trouble. Check it or drop it.
  • Tragedies as entertainment. A disaster in the news is not a call-in game. Cover it with care, or not at all.
  • Crisis topics without support. Give a helpline before you take calls about suicide, abuse or addiction.
  • One-sided rants. Politics and religion can work, but only with a real second voice in the room.
  • Callers' private details. Never read out a caller's address, or a phone number they didn't ask you to give out.
  • Advice you're not qualified to give. Medical, legal and money questions go to a qualified guest.
  • Inside jokes. If a new listener needs the backstory, explain it in one line or drop it.
Was this helpful?

Thanks for telling us.

Sorry about that. Tell us what was missing and we'll fix the post.

CloudRadio One

Ready to put this on air?

  • AutoDJ keeps your station playing around the clock
  • Go live from the software you already use
  • A player for your website
  • Unlimited listeners

One plan, everything included. No contracts, cancel anytime.